Scott Patterson may be best known as Luke Danes, the grumpy yet lovable diner owner from Gilmore Girls, but his story started long before Stars Hollow. Patterson didn’t begin his career as an actor at all — he was a professional baseball player. Yep, before pouring endless cups of coffee for Lorelai and Rory, he was pitching for teams like the Atlanta Braves’ farm system.

When his baseball career ended, Patterson turned his focus to acting, studying with legendary teachers and slowly working his way into television and film. His big break came when he landed the role of Luke Danes in Gilmore Girls, becoming the plaid-shirted, backwards-cap-wearing heart of the show. Luke was sarcastic, stubborn, and secretly the nicest guy in town — and Patterson played him with a perfect mix of gruffness and heart.

Since then, Patterson has appeared in a variety of projects, including roles in the Saw franchise (yes, Luke Danes went from pouring coffee to surviving Jigsaw’s traps — talk about a career pivot). He’s also appeared in Aliens in America and reprised his role as Luke in the Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life revival, giving fans exactly what they’d been waiting for.

Outside of acting, Patterson is a musician and even has his own coffee brand — which feels very on-brand for a guy who spent seven seasons running a fictional diner. He’s also an avid painter and has spoken about his love for visual arts.

Scott Patterson’s career is proof that you can start in one field, take a completely different path, and still hit a home run (or maybe a triple shot espresso). On his birthday, we celebrate the man who made Stars Hollow a little warmer — and a lot more caffeinated.

Happy Birthday, Scott Patterson!