The Duchess Who Wasn’t Day

Reflecting on a Past of Inequality

The Duchess Who Wasn’t Day is a lesser-known observance that offers an opportunity to reflect on the struggles and triumphs of women throughout history. While the day itself centers around the life and works of Irish author Margaret Wolfe Hungerford, often attributed as "The Duchess," it also serves as a poignant reminder of the broader societal context in which women once lived—times when their rights were severely restricted, their voices often silenced, and their potential stifled by rigid gender roles.

A Woman of Talent in a Restrictive Era

Margaret Wolfe Hungerford, born into a relatively comfortable Anglo-Irish family in 1855, demonstrated literary talent from a young age. Growing up in an era where women’s intellectual pursuits were often relegated to hobbies rather than careers, Hungerford faced the typical societal expectations placed upon women of her time. These expectations dictated that a woman’s primary role was as a wife and mother, with little room for professional aspirations outside the domestic sphere. Despite these constraints, Hungerford pursued her passion for writing, eventually carving out a niche for herself in the literary world—a remarkable feat given the restrictive environment in which she lived.

From a young age, Hungerford was an avid reader, devouring the works of authors like Jane Austen, the Brontë sisters, and Charles Dickens. These literary influences shaped her writing style, which blended sharp social observation with a keen understanding of human relationships. However, unlike some of her literary predecessors who had the advantage of writing from positions of relative independence or anonymity, Hungerford was deeply embedded in the societal norms that limited women’s roles.

After marrying at the age of 18, Hungerford’s life became even more challenging. As a married woman, she was expected to prioritize her duties as a wife and mother above all else. In 19th-century Ireland, as in much of the world, the domestic responsibilities of women were seen as their primary—and often sole—purpose. Yet, Hungerford found ways to balance these responsibilities with her writing, often penning her novels and stories during the few quiet moments of the day when her children were asleep or otherwise occupied.

Writing under the pen name "The Duchess" allowed Hungerford to maintain a degree of privacy and control over her work that might have been impossible had she published under her real name. The use of a pseudonym was a common practice among women writers of the time, not only to shield themselves from public scrutiny but also to ensure their work was taken seriously in a male-dominated literary marketplace. "The Duchess" was an intriguing choice—suggesting nobility and sophistication, perhaps a subtle nod to the irony of a woman of such talent having to mask her identity in order to succeed.

Hungerford’s novels were immensely popular in her time, particularly among women readers who found her stories of love, marriage, and society both entertaining and relatable. Her most famous work, Molly Bawn, was a bestseller and helped cement her reputation as a leading novelist of the day. The novel's portrayal of a strong-willed, independent heroine who navigates the challenges of love and society struck a chord with readers, particularly women who saw in Molly Bawn a reflection of their own struggles for autonomy and respect.

Despite her success, Hungerford was never fully recognized by the literary establishment, which was dominated by male critics and scholars. Her works were often dismissed as mere "women’s fiction"—a genre that, while popular, was not considered to have the same literary merit as the works of her male contemporaries. This marginalization was reflective of the broader societal attitudes toward women’s contributions to literature and the arts. Women writers were often pigeonholed into specific genres or themes, and their work was rarely afforded the same level of critical engagement as that of their male peers.

Furthermore, Hungerford’s prolific output was sometimes viewed with suspicion. The fact that she could produce so many novels while managing a household led some to question the quality of her work, as if a woman’s creative capacity was inherently limited by her domestic obligations. Yet, Hungerford’s ability to juggle her roles as a wife, mother, and writer speaks to her extraordinary discipline and determination.

Hungerford’s career, though successful in many respects, also highlighted the limitations placed on women of her era. She was a woman of immense talent, yet her need to write under a pseudonym and the lack of serious critical recognition she received are indicative of the broader societal constraints that shaped her life and work. Despite these challenges, Hungerford’s novels continued to be popular even after her death, and her legacy as "The Duchess" lives on as a testament to the perseverance and creativity of women writers who, like her, navigated and often resisted the restrictions of their time.

Women’s Rights in the 19th Century

The 19th century was a time of significant social change, but progress in women’s rights was slow and hard-fought. In the early part of the century, women were largely excluded from formal education. Higher education, in particular, was a male preserve, and women who sought intellectual pursuits often had to do so in secret or through private tutors. The lack of educational opportunities kept many women economically dependent on men, reinforcing the societal belief that a woman’s place was in the home.

Marriage laws of the time further entrenched gender inequality. Under the doctrine of coverture, a married woman’s legal identity was subsumed under that of her husband. She could not own property, enter into contracts, or even control her own wages. Any wealth or inheritance she brought into the marriage automatically became her husband’s. Divorce, which was difficult and scandalous to obtain, usually favored the husband, often leaving women destitute and without custody of their children.

Women also had no political rights. They were denied the vote, and the idea of women participating in public life was met with widespread resistance. The suffrage movement, which began to gain momentum in the mid-19th century, faced fierce opposition from both men and women who believed that politics was beyond a woman’s understanding or interest.

Seeds of Change

Despite these oppressive conditions, the 19th century also saw the beginnings of significant movements toward gender equality. Women began to organize, advocating for rights in areas such as property ownership, education, and voting. The first women’s rights convention, held in Seneca Falls, New York, in 1848, marked a pivotal moment in the fight for women’s suffrage in the United States. Similar movements began to take shape in Europe and other parts of the world.

Education became a key battleground. Reformers like Mary Wollstonecraft in England and Elizabeth Cady Stanton in the United States argued that women were intellectually equal to men and deserved the same educational opportunities. The establishment of women’s colleges in the mid-19th century was a significant step forward, offering women the chance to pursue higher education and professional careers.

The legal landscape also began to shift. The Married Women’s Property Act of 1870 in the UK, for example, allowed married women to own and control property in their own right for the first time. This was a significant, though limited, victory, as it began to erode the legal doctrine of coverture and recognize women as individuals with their own rights.

The Legacy of The Duchess Who Wasn’t

The life and work of Margaret Wolfe Hungerford remind us of the resilience and creativity of women who navigated and often pushed against the constraints of their time. Hungerford’s success as a writer, even under a pseudonym, demonstrated the power of women’s voices to influence culture and society, even when those voices were not fully recognized or valued.

The Duchess Who Wasn’t Day is an opportunity to reflect on how far we have come in the fight for gender equality but also to recognize the struggles that remain. While women today enjoy far more rights and opportunities than in the past, the journey toward true equality is ongoing. Gender pay gaps, underrepresentation in leadership positions, and societal expectations that limit women’s roles are just a few of the challenges that continue to persist.

In honoring The Duchess Who Wasn’t, we not only celebrate Margaret Wolfe Hungerford’s contributions to literature but also remember the countless women who fought—and continue to fight—for a world where their rights and talents are fully recognized and valued.

Please Share our Content